Newcastle United vs Everton FC, English Premier League 2025-26, Today Match Prediction

Newcastle United vs Everton FC Match Prediction & Analysis

Both sides carry genuine uncertainty into Saturday's clash at St. James' Park, with form dipping at precisely the wrong moment for each. Furthermore, the hosts desperately need home wins to rebuild supporter confidence, whereas Everton will fancy exploiting a Newcastle backline that has looked increasingly vulnerable without several key absentees. 

Newcastle's Nick Woltemade has quietly emerged as their most productive attacking outlet this season, registering 7 goals and 2 assists across 24 league appearances, and his physical presence will trouble Everton's defence considerably. 

Iliman Ndiaye, meanwhile, brings 5 goals and 2 assists from just 21 league games for the Toffees, offering unpredictable movement that Newcastle's injury-depleted backline must track carefully throughout.

Current Standings: Newcastle currently sit 11th in the Premier League table on 36 points, while Everton occupy 9th position just one point ahead on 37, with both sides separated by the narrowest of margins.

Head-to-Head Stats: Across all competitions historically, Everton hold a narrow overall edge with 71 wins to Newcastle's 69, while 38 meetings between the two sides have finished level.

TEAMS PREVIEW

Newcastle United Preview

Newcastle go into Saturday's fixture carrying a league-wide average of 1.41 goals scored per game across 27 Premier League appearances, but their defensive record tells a more troubling story. The Magpies are conceding at a rate of 1.44 goals per game, leaving them with a goal difference of just -1 overall.

Their last five Premier League outings have been particularly painful, yielding only 6 goals scored against a staggering 12 conceded, with defeats to Liverpool (1-4), Aston Villa (0-2), Brentford (2-3) and Manchester City (1-2) sandwiching a solitary win at Tottenham. That run confirms four losses from five, and the confidence around St. James' Park is visibly low.

On the European front, Newcastle United delivered two commanding performances in the group stage against Qarabag FK, winning 3-2 at home and then demolishing them 6-1 away, showing they can still produce when the defensive pressure eases.

Team news, though, severely complicates the picture for Eddie Howe. Bruno Guimarães (muscle, mid-April), Fabian Schär (ankle, mid-April), Tino Livramento (hamstring, mid-March), Lewis Miley (knee, early March), and Emil Krafth (knee, early June) are all ruled out. 

Newcastle United (4-1-4-1): Nick Pope - Kieran Trippier, Malick Thiaw, Daniel Burn, Lewis Hall - Sandro Tonali - Anthony Elanga, Jacob Ramsey, Nick Woltemade, Joseph Willock - Anthony Gordon.

Everton FC Preview

Everton arrive at St. James' Park sitting 9th in the Premier League table. The Toffees are producing a moderate scoring rate of 1.07 goals per game from 27 appearances. It is a figure that reflects their tendency to grind out results rather than dominate opponents with attacking flair. Defensively, the Toffees concede at 1.15 goals per game, giving them a goal difference of -2. However, that modest number masks a squad that has shown genuine resilience across stretches of the season.

Their last five league outings, however, present a mixed picture. Everton scored just 5 goals across those fixtures while conceding 6, with back-to-back defeats to Bournemouth (1-2) and Manchester United (0-1) bookending a run that also featured wins at Fulham (2-1) and draws against Brighton (1-1) and Leeds United (1-1). Consequently, two points from the last two games create real pressure heading into this fixture.

On the European front, Everton do not feature in continental competition this season. It means Saturday's league game commands their complete focus without any fixture congestion to factor in.

Regarding team news, Jack Grealish remains the sole confirmed absentee. He is sidelined with a broken foot until early May 2026, which otherwise leaves David Moyes with a largely fit and available squad to select from at St. James' Park. 

Everton (4-2-3-1): Jordan Pickford - James Garner, James Tarkowski, Michael Keane, Jarrad Branthwaite - Tim Iroegbunam, Idrissa Gana Gueye - Iliman Ndiaye, Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall, Harrison Armstrong - Thierno Barry.

NEWCASTLE UNITED vs EVERTON FC
Winning Prediction

Newcastle's home advantage and superior squad depth, despite their recent wobbles, should prove decisive against an Everton side that have scored just once across their last two fixtures. Consequently, a narrow home win looks the most probable outcome, with a 2-1 Newcastle victory the predicted scoreline. The most profitable bet points to Both Teams to Score at odds, given both defences have leaked freely this month. 

Newcastle United to win (2-1)

1xBet

330% up to ₹65,000 on your 1st Deposit with Reg Code: TOPBK

BET NOW